A Deceptively Simple Question
Last month, the CEO of a consumer electronics manufacturer asked me a deceptively simple question: “What is the real added value of an intelligence department?”
He continued: “I know what the department costs. Every month, I can see what we spend on salaries, subscriptions and information management systems. But what does it actually deliver?” In other words: what’s the bang for the buck?
It’s a fair question. Sales is usually seen as a profit center. An intelligence department, on the other hand, is often viewed as a cost center, and its contribution can be much harder to see on the balance sheet. So the CEO’s challenge was straightforward: “Can you actually put a monetary value on what intelligence delivers?”
“Yes,” I replied.
Two Ways to Approach It
We have a comprehensive approach for calculating the ROI of intelligence. It looks at the different components of intelligence and combines several perspectives, including integral and differential approaches, as well as internal and external ROI. And there are two ways we can approach it.
First, we can do it for you. We analyze the expenditure, examine how intelligence is used throughout the organization, and apply different methods to determine what it generates, both directly and indirectly, and in terms of both hard and soft returns.
Second, we can teach your own people how to do it. We work with colleagues from strategy, marketing, finance or other relevant functions, showing them how to calculate and assess the value of intelligence themselves.
In practice, we have found that the most effective approach is often a combination of the two: working together with the organization while transferring the knowledge at the same time. It is essentially learning by example. We demonstrate the process, explain the different methodologies, discuss their strengths and weaknesses, and help the organization determine which approach works best in its own context.
Because there is no single magic formula. To obtain a reliable picture, you need to use different methods in parallel and apply a process of triangulation. There are also several challenges to overcome: time spans and data issues, the difficulty of isolating the impact of intelligence, and what we sometimes call the “beta factor”: the extent to which an intelligence effort actually contributes to an outcome. And that is only part of the story, because there is much more we can do to give substance to the ROI of intelligence.
The CEO was listening carefully. “So,” I continued, “why don’t we draw up a plan and discuss it with you and your team?” He agreed. No sooner said than done.
Eight Sessions and an Eye-Opener
We agreed to schedule eight sessions of four hours each.
The first session focused on the fundamentals: what ROI actually means, how it differs from concepts such as ROCE, and, most importantly, why measuring ROI becomes difficult when the impact cannot be observed directly. For the company, this was already something of an eye-opener.
The following sessions were more hands-on. We systematically reviewed how intelligence was being used across the organization and applied different models to assess its added value. As part of the deal, we also conducted a survey and interviewed intelligence users to understand where and how intelligence was influencing decisions and outcomes.
The Result? Better Than Expected
The estimated direct and indirect added value of intelligence was 2.85 times the total cost:
- The intelligence department cost approximately €700,000.
- Its estimated contribution was close to €2 million.
- That means an ROI of approximately 185%. For every euro invested, the organization generated an estimated €2.85 in value.
A very pleasant surprise. And it didn’t stop there: with a few relatively simple adjustments we recommended, the intelligence team was able to increase its ROI even further.
The More Important Question
So perhaps the more important question isn’t “What does our intelligence department cost?” but “What value are we actually getting from it, and how much more value could we be getting?”
Does this sound familiar? Do you also find yourself wondering what your intelligence function really delivers? We can help you find the answer and, more importantly, put a value on it.